links · people · groups · tags | My: links · tags · groups · watchlists · notes login · sign up now! | help · blog
Simpy simpy
 
Bill Hooker, member since Jan 4, 2006
.
Search Everyone: "stuartshieber",
1 - 3 of 3   Watch sennoma
 
There is an economic solution to the problem that bears consideration: Charge for submission. This would induce self-selection; authors would be loathe to submit unless they thought the paper had a fair chance of acceptance. Consider a conference or journal with a 25% acceptance rate that charged, say, $50 per submission. (The right amount may be different; I use this figure just as an example.) Authors who tended to write and submit average quality papers would be confronted with a cost of some $200 (in expectation) per published paper. If they wanted to reduce that cost, the expedient method would be to submit fewer papers and papers with higher average quality. The most plausible approach is to refrain from submitting the lowest quality papers, but other methods of improving quality would work as well. This has several positive effects: reduced reviewing load, higher average submission quality, less “salami-slicing“, and revenue generation to boot. To avoid disenfranchisement of scholars with more limited means, fee waivers should be supplied in exigent circumstances, as they are for page, figure, and other publication charges by many journals. The application process for the fee waiver would be separated from the editorial process to prevent mercenary considerations from affecting editorial decisions. Submission fees have a further benefit over publication fees in eliminating any economic incentive for lowering quality standards as a means for increasing revenue, as discussed in detail by McCabe and Snyder.
by sennoma 2009-06-23 01:43 peerreview · stuartshieber
http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/pamphlet/2009/06/15/an-economic-solution-to-reviewing-load - cached - mail it - history
by sennoma 2009-06-05 18:19 lostart · oa · stuartshieber
http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/pamphlet/2009/05/29/what-percentage-of-open-access-journals-charge-publication-fees/comment... - cached - mail it - history
by sennoma 2009-06-05 17:42 oa · academicfreedom · stuartshieber
http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/pamphlet/2009/05/28/open-access-policies-and-academic-freedom - cached - mail it - history
1 - 3 of 3  
Related Tags
 
- exclude ~ optional + require
Add Dates